| Henry | Oliver | USL All-American, First Team All-State | MICDS | Boston University | 2025 |
| Alex | Bentley | Second Team All-State | De Smet Jesuit | Elmhurst University | 2024 |
| Willy | Carpenter | First Team All-State | MICDS | Washington and Lee | 2024 |
| Jack | Littauer | First Team All-State | De Smet Jesuit | Lindenwood University | 2024 |
| Jacob | Price | First Team All-Conference | CBC | University of Missouri | 2024 |
| Jack | Bichelmeyer | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Rockhurst High | The Ohio State University | 2024 |
| Bennett | Breheny | Second Team All-State | Vianney | University of Missouri | 2024 |
| Garrett | Verstraete | First Team All-Conference | Webster Groves | University of Missouri | 2024 |
| Johnny | Schlattman | First Team All-State | Chaminade | University of Missouri | 2024 |
| George | Herron
| USL All-American, First Team All-State | MICDS | Bucknell University | 2023 |
| Jacob | Goldstein | First Team All-State | Ladue High | Gettysburg College | 2023 |
| Brock | Narciso | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Rockhurst High | Trinity University | 2023 |
| Danny | Campbell | First Team All-State | SLUH | Hobart University | 2023 |
| Mark | Mintzlaff | First Team All-State | MICDS | Ohio Northern University | 2022 |
| Joe | Cavanaugh | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Chaminade | | 2022 |
| Bryce | Sullivan | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Chaminade | | 2022 |
| Chris | Anderson | USL All-American, First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | Cleveland State | 2022 |
| Kyle | Granquist | First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | Centre College | 2022 |
| Tyler | Forestel | | Vianney | Aurora University | 2022 |
| Jake | Mitchell | First Team All-State | CBC | Wagner College | 2022 |
| Nick | Witcher | | SLUH | Centre College | 2022 |
| Landon | Gelven | USL All-American, St. Louis Post Dispatch Player Of The Year, First Team All-State | MICDS | Saint Joseph's University | 2022 |
| PJ | Behan | USL All-American, Inside Lacrosse All-American First Team All-State | MICDS | Brown University | 2022 |
| Kai | Tschudy | First Team All-State | MICDS | Denver University | 2022 |
| Gavin | Bomstad | USL All-American, First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | Tampa University | 2022 |
| Quinn | Sweeney | Second Team All-State | Lindbergh High | Maryville University | 2022 |
| Will | Wynn | | | Rockhurst Universty | 2021 |
| Beckett | Tasker | | John Burroughs | Depauw | 2021 |
| Jake | Bacilek | | Webster Groves | Palm Beach Atlantic | 2021 |
| Jake | Gisi | | Chaminade | Illinois Wesleyan University | 2021 |
| Wesley | Prada | | CBC | Harford CC | 2021 |
| Will | Kacmarek | USL All-American, St. Louis Post Dispatch Player Of The Year, First Team All-State | MICDS | Ohio University (D1 Football) | 2021 |
| Will | Beldner | | CBC | Alabama Huntsville | 2021 |
| Drew | Altic | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Chaminade | Rockhurst University | 2021 |
| Crawford | Bundy | USL All-American, St. Louis Post Dispatch Player Of The Year (2x), First Team All-State | MICDS | Georgetown University | 2021 |
| Nolan | Ruder | First Team All-State | De Smet | Saint John Fischer | 2021 |
| Grant | Mikesell | | | Edgewater University | 2021 |
| Luke | Kane | | Webster Groves | Pflager University | 2021 |
| Braeden | Williams | Adrenaline All-American, UA All-American, First Team All-State | Lafayette | High Point/Tampa University | 2020 |
| Jordan | Celeslie | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Vianney | Marquette University | 2019 |
| Nico | Feldman | First Team All-State | MICDS | Denison University | 2019 |
| Graham | Childs | | | Hofstra University | 2019 |
| Cooper | Prawdzik | | | Denver University | 2019 |
| Colin | Penn | | | Rutgers University | 2019 |
| Andrew | DiFrancesco | | | Denver University | 2019 |
| Quentin | Matsui | | | Virginia University | 2019 |
| Thomas | Niedringhaus | USL All-American, First Team All-State | MICDS | Boston University | 2019 |
| Henry | Carpenter | First Team All-State | MICDS | Penn State University | 2019 |
| Chris | Handy | | Chaminade | Denver University | 2019 |
| Elijah | Myers | | Ladue | North Carolina | 2019 |
| Luke | Wetzel | First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | | 2019 |
| Graham | Bundy Jr | Team USA U21 Captain, USL All-American, St. Louis Post Dispatch Player Of The Year, First Team All-State | MICDS | Georgetown | 2019 |
| Jayson | Sugavanam | USL All-American, First Team All-State | MICDS | | 2019 |
| Chase | Baker | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Eureka | | 2019 |
| Alexander | Feldman | USL All-American, First Team All-State | MICDS | Denison University | 2018 |
| Peter | Covington | First Team All-State | Chaminade | Lindenwood University | 2018 |
| Ross | Buchman | First Team All-State | MICDS | University of Vermont | 2018 |
| Derek | Radke | First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | Cleveland State University | 2017 |
| Ben | Jackson | First Team All-State | Chaminade | Lynn University | 2017 |
| Wit | Tegenkamp | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Webster Groves | Rockhurst University | 2017 |
| Nolan | Corker | First Team All-State | SLUH | Lindenwood University | 2017 |
| Patrick | Howley | | SLUH | Rockhurst University | 2017 |
| Harry | Wellford | USL All-American, St. Louis Post Dispatch Player Of The Year, First Team All-State | MICDS | University of Virginia | 2017 |
| Austen | King | First Team All-State | Ft. Zumwalt | Lindenwood | 2017 |
| Bryce | Horstman | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Lafayette | Mount St. Mary's University | 2017 |
| Banks | Pflager | First Team All-State | MICDS | Washington and Lee | 2016 |
| Matt | Trowbridge | USL All-American, St. Louis Post Dispatch Player Of The Year, First Team All-State | MICDS | University of Michigan | 2016 |
| Jake | Burmeister | USL All-American, First Team All-State | MICDS | Lehigh University | 2016 |
| John | Binder | USL All-American, First Team All-State | MICDS | | 2016 |
| Alex | Bean | USL All-American, First Team All-State | MICDS | Georgetown University | 2016 |
| Sean | Conway | First Team All-State | Eureka | Rockhurst University | 2015 |
| Michael | Snodgrass | First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | Lindenwood University | 2015 |
| Gabe | Remshardt | First Team All-State | Clayton | Bryant University | 2015 |
| Chase | Littiken | | CBC | Rockhurst University | 2015 |
| Sean | Dotson | First Team All-State | Wentzville | Rockhurst University | 2015 |
| Brendan | Duggan | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Lafayette | Onedoga College | 2015 |
| Paul | Rougeau | | DeSmet Jesuit | McGill University | 2015 |
| Noah | Iverson | USL All-American, St. Louis Post Dispatch Player Of The Year, First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | John Carroll University | 2015 |
| Craig | Koester | First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | Lynchburg College | 2015 |
| Louis | Martinez | First Team All-State | CBC | Rockhurst University | 2014 |
| Michael | Beckham | USL All-American, First Team All-State | CBC | Rockhurst University | 2014 |
| Ian | Meister | First Team All-State | CBC | Rockhurst University | 2014 |
| Connor | Eskridge | First Team All-State | Vianney | Lindenwood | 2014 |
| Gabe | Monteleone | First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | Lindenwood University | 2014 |
| JT | Thiemann | USL All-American, St. Louis Post Dispatch Player Of The Year, First Team All-State | MICDS | | 2014 |
| Max | Keeley | USL All-American, St. Louis Post Dispatch Player Of The Year, First Team All-State | CBC | Amherst College | 2014 |
| Christian | Schveninger | First Team All-State | CBC | Florida Southern University | 2013 |
| Zach | Turnure | USL All-American, First Team All-State | CBC | The Ohio State University | 2013 |
| Benj | Besancenez | USL All-American, First Team All-State | DeSmet Jesuit | Lindenwood University | 2013 |
| John | Coulter | First Team All-State | MICDS | Denison University | 2013 |
| Jon | Vogel | USL All-American, First Team All-State | Parkway West | College of the Holy Cross | 2013 |
| Will | Morehead | USL All-American, First Team All-State | MICDS | Providence College | 2013 |
| Stephen | Lordo | First Team All-State | SLUH | Robert Morris University | 2013 |
| Justin | Mayfield | USL All-American, First Team All-State | SLUH | Robert Morris University | 2013 |
